7.24.2006

So what WAS it about?

George Grant relays these words spoken by Ulysses S. Grant, the last Northern General of the Civil War, and a slave-owner until it was illegal:
"If the war had been about slavery,' he [Ulysses] 'would have fought for the South."

George Grant continues:
"Ironically, his greatest on-the-field adversary, Robert E. Lee had stated exactly the opposite sentiment."

In other words, Lee would have said yes when the North asked him to lead them, if Lee thought the war was about slavery.

7.18.2006

A fourth blessing

Zachariah Amadeus Hemmeke was born to Sara and me at 4:02pm, Monday July 17.
8 lbs, 3 oz., 20 inches long, he'll be an equal match for Grace (4), Owen (3), and Isaiah (2) in a few years!

Zachariah is Hebrew, meaning "God remembers."
Amadeus is Latin, meaning "lover of God."



7.17.2006

Valued heritage or crusty tradition?

Jeff Meyers is an interesting mix of old and new. While in the conservative Reformed tradition (PCA), he is quite critical of it at certain points. He’s getting in trouble for saying this:

“The sixteenth- and seventeenth-century confessions and catechisms are no longer sufficient guides for the modern church.”

But then, he clarifies that his concern is one of engaging present culture, not revising those confessions’ interpretation of Scripture.

“I fear that many Reformed men escape into the past…. We love the Puritans more than we love our own generation, and it often seems more than we love digging into the Bible for fresh, relevant answers to modern problems…. If we want to be an enclave of ecclesiastical romantics living in the 17th century, a tribe of irrelevant theologues, then by all means let’s continue to multiply conferences and books on the glory of Westminster. Let’s continue to demand subscription to every jot and tittle of our precious unreformable tradition. Let’s attack anyone who suggests updates and changes. If, however, we desire to minister to people in our world, we need to stand on the shoulders of our glorious forefathers in the faith and do what they did—preach, write, and formulate answers from the Bible for the people of our generation!"

7.15.2006

More right Wright

"For [Paul], being 'in Christ'... means 'belonging to the people of God as redefined around the Messiah.'... a specifically covenantal way of speaking" (pg 152).

"The Gospel reveals... God's covenant faithfulness" (153).

"The Gospel is not... a set of techniques for making people Christians.... The Gospel is the announcement that Jesus is Lord - Lord of the world, Lord of the cosmos, Lord of the earth, of the ozone layer, of whales and waterfalls, of trees and tortoises.... we cannot make that announcement without seeking to bring that Lordship to bear over every aspect of the world.... there is no area of existence or life... that is exempt from the summons to allegiance. Perhaps one reason why some have shied away from seeing Jesus' Messiahship as a central part of Paul's Gospel has been the tacit recognition that it is much easier to turn Christianity into... a private system of piety which doesn't impinge on the public world." (153-4).

"This is not a matter... of 'bringing politics into religion.' It is bringing the whole world under the Lordship of Christ" (155).

"[The Gospel] is not a take-it-or-leave-it thing. No herald in the ancient world would say, 'Tiberius Caesar has become Emperor: accept him if it suits you.' The Gospel is, then, the announcement about Jesus, not in itself the offer of a new experience. Whatever new experiences result from giving one's allegiance to Jesus are just that, a bunch of new experiences" (157).

It seems Wright's main concern is avoiding the relegating of spirituality to a ghetto irrelevant to public life, which happens a lot in the evangelical world. He isn't saying the offer of the Gospel, or the resulting experiences are unimportant; he just wants to accent the public announcement of Jesus being Lord.

This was interesting to read right after finishing Lord of the Rings, where the hobbits scour the Shire by announcing the downfall of Sauron and Saruman. That announcement had lots of effect on how the shire turned out. Frodo and Sam didn't just go to church more often.

Wright's concern is the public impact of the Gospel, I think.

Baby Blitz

What does a 8.75 month pregnant woman do on the hottest weekend of the year (95 degrees)? She spends hours sitting under a quilt!! I started sewing a baby quilt for Hemmeke #4 on Thursday and plan to finish it tonight. Crazy, eh? Wait... it gets better.

I also finished my Hot Lava Cardigan which is made of bulky weight 100% baby alpaca wool. So when I haven't been under a quilt, a nice warm wool sweater has been in my lap. I'm not sure if the sweater fits me or not - I had to guess at what size I'll be, pretty sure that I'll be smaller than I am now! The entire thing might get frogged if it's not just right - this yarn is too dreamy to waste on an ill-fitting cardi.

And if that's not enough, yesterday I started knitting a pair of wee little socks for Jr. to wear in the hospital. One down, one to go. Grandma VO doesn't think they're big enough to get on his little piggies, but I remember how scrawny baby ankles are! Babies are cute, but their feet are ugly, so a sweet pair of socks to cover up will get baby going in this world in style. OK, with 90 degree weather, he'll most likely outgrow them before he ever wears them, in which case they get turned into his first Christmas tree ornament.

Pics of all finished objects (FOs) - human and not - to come soon!

Milton Friedman

Got my latest Imprimis today, an interview with the great free-market economist Milton Friedman. Here are excerpts:

"the first step following the 2003 invasion of Iraq should have been the privatization of the oil fields. If the government had given every individual over 21 years of age equal shares in a corporation that had the right and responsibility to make appropriate arrangements with foreign oil companies for the purpose of discovering and developing Iraq's oil reserves, the oil income would have flowed in the form of dividends to the people—the shareholders—rather than into government coffers. This would have provided an income to the whole people of Iraq and thereby prevented the current disputes over oil between the Sunnis, Shiites and Kurds, because oil income would have been distributed on an individual rather than a group basis.

"We have a socialist-communist system of distributing medical care. Instead of letting people hire their own physicians and pay them, no one pays his or her own medical bills. Instead, there's a third party payment system. It is a communist system and it has a communist result. Despite this, we've had numerous miracles in medical science. From the discovery of penicillin, to new surgical techniques, to MRIs and CAT scans, the last 30 or 40 years have been a period of miraculous change in medical science. On the other hand, we've seen costs skyrocket. Nobody is happy: physicians don't like it, patients don't like it. Why? Because none of them are responsible for themselves. You no longer have a situation in which a patient chooses a physician, receives a service, gets charged, and pays for it. There is no direct relation between the patient and the physician. The physician is an employee of an insurance company or an employee of the government. Today, a third party pays the bills. As a result, no one who visits the doctor asks what the charge is going to be—somebody else is going to take care of that. The end result is third party payment and, worst of all, third party treatment.

"The economic situation during the past 20 years has been unprecedented in the history of the world. You will find no other 20-year period in which prices have been as stable—relatively speaking—in which there has been as little variability in price levels, in which inflation has been so well-controlled, and in which output has gone up as regularly. You hear all this talk about economic difficulties, when the fact is we are at the absolute peak of prosperity in the history of the world. Never before have so many people had as much as they do today. I believe a large part of that is to be attributed to better monetary policy. The improved policy is a result of the acceptance of the view that inflation is a monetary phenomenon, not a real phenomenon. We have accepted the view that central banks are primarily responsible for maintaining stable prices and nothing else.

"Unfortunately, it is still the case that if you ask people what caused the Great Depression, nine out of ten will probably tell you it was a failure of business. But it's absolutely clear that the Depression was a failure of government and not a failure of business.

"Before government had any involvement in education, the majority of youngsters were schooled, literate, and able to learn. It is a disgrace that in a country like the United States, 30 percent of youngsters never graduate from high school.

"The 1994 Contract with America called for the elimination of the Department of Education. Since then, the budget for the Department of Education has tripled. This trend must be reversed. Next, education ought to be a parental matter. The responsibility for educating children is with parents. But in order to make it a parental matter, we must have a situation in which parents are Free to Choose the schools their children attend.

"self-interest is what the individual wants. Mother Teresa, to take one example, operated on a completely self-interested basis. Self-interest does not mean narrow self-interest. Self-interest does not mean monetary self-interest. Self-interest means pursuing those things that are valuable to you but which you can also persuade others to value. Such things very often go beyond immediate material interest."

The Limitations of Preaching

"Preaching at its best helps us worship, inspires, informs and motivates us for discipleship. Unfortunately, too many settle for the performace of preaching without engaging the content of preaching. People rate preaching as they would a movie. Even when they appreciate what is said at the time, they quickly forget or ignore what has been preached, with little personal response."

Ron Geschwendt, Sunday School Guide, July 2, 2006

7.14.2006

To the 10th Generation

These days I look forward to my issue of Tabletalk for the articles by Warren Gage, of Knox Seminary. His typology in history is always amazing. Gage's article in the July issue has a great insight on division within the family of God.

When Abraham and Lot divided, the Ammonites and Moabites came from Lot. Later, the law excludes them from the assembly for 10 generations (Deuteronomy 23:3). But guess who is the 10th generation from Abraham? A certain man name Boaz. And who did he happen to marry? A Moabite named Ruth. This is a foretaste of the perfect unity God will bring to His family at the end.

Come, Lord Jesus.

7.12.2006

Whoa, wait a minute...

You're still at the Hemmeke blog - we somehow lost our template we raided from another site. So I welcome you to the new temporary look you'll find here in the next few days. All the goodies are lost from the sidebar, but we'll work on getting those back up (and trimming them down) for your navigational ease.

We aim to please - any useful ideas to share to make this blog more user-friendly?

Wright, again

Wright's argument is stronger when he comes to Romans. He looks at 3:21-26, 10:2-4, and 1:16-17, and his distinction comes into clearer focus - that is, Wright's distinction between God's own righteousness (His being true to His word and His ruling justly) and the righteousness by which we are cleared of guilt and can come before God. Romans 3:25-26 makes this point very clearly - that Paul is talking about the former, not the latter, righteousness - God's own. Jesus' death on the cross clears a shadow on God's reputation as a just judge. He had left so much sin unpunished, Israel was beginning to wonder. But now it's all clear: ALL have sinned (Israel too) and are made righteous through Jesus' sacrifice.

Wright wants to emphasize God's own righteousness, because he wants to avoid seeing our salvation as a merely forensic and legal transaction. This obscures the love of God, which drove Christ to the cross in the first place. And I agree completely, as long as we don't end up denying that to be spared God's wrath, we must have a righteousness not our own, reckoned (imputed) to our account. But absolutely, love motivates the transaction.

D.M. Lloyd-Jones makes the exact same point in a Banner of Truth booklet, "The Cross: The Vindication of God," more than 40 years ago. There's nothing new here.

So Wright's point is that Paul's phrase "righteousness of God" doesn't refer to our acceptable standing before God, but to God's own righteousness. But when he comes to Romans 1:17, I think I have a problem. "For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ, for it is the power of God to salvation for everyone who believes, for the Jew first and also for the Greek. For in it the righteousness of God is revealed from faith to faith; as it is written, “The just [righteous] shall live by faith.” Wright makes a strong distinction between God's righteousness and our own. Paul talks most about the former, Wright says. But this strong distinction misses something here in 1:16-17. Vs 16, I agree, Paul is talking about God's own righteousness, but then he elaborates on it by quoting Hab 2:4, which appears to me to refer to the righteousness of God's people, not God's own righteousness. In other words, Paul uses righteousness in two different ways in these two verses, and uses one way to explain what he meant by the other way! That doesn't sound like a very strong distinction to me.

The whole point of the Incarnation of our Lord Jesus Christ was to bring holiness back to men, and that only God could do that. We are called to bear God's image, to be like Him. So, remembering obvious Creator-creature distinctions, the righteousness of God should be blurred a bit, as people begin to see Jesus through the mirror of our lives.

7.11.2006

The Righteousness of God

Well, here it comes. Wright thinks this phrase, a trademark of Paul, means God's own righteousness, His acting justly, and not a righteousness that He gives to us to make us acceptable before Him. I disagree, not seeing the need for an either/or here. I think Wright is on to something when he brings into our reading of Paul the Jewish understanding of God's covenant faithfulness to Israel. But there is no need to reject the Reformation's hallmark view of justification and imputed righteousness in order to grasp it.

Objections to Wright, affirming imputed righteousness often point to passages like 2 Corinthians 5:21: "He made Him who knew no sin to be sin for us, that we might become the righteousness of God in Him." Wright answers by maintaining that (a)Paul is referring to the apostles' own ministry of reconciliation - that they are embodying God's righteousness, not to a general imputation principle; and that (b)if it refers to imputation then it doesn't fit with the rest of the chapter. But if Wright is right about (a), then who did God make Jesus sin FOR? Who is the "we" in verse 21? Only Paul or the apostles? And (b) doesn't make sense, because vs 19 refers directly to imputation of sin. The entire substance of the ministry of reconciliation is the imputation of God's righteousness to us, so that we CAN be reconciled!

Wright has yet to deal with Romans; maybe he'll convince me there. And I don't want to underestimate the validity of the "New Perspective" of Paul's Jewish roots and God's faithfulness to Israel, seen in His resurrection of His Messiah, the redeemer of Israel.

7.10.2006

Laughing at ourselves

We come from Dutch roots, as do many people in west Michigan (hence town names like Holland, Vriesland, Drenthe, Zeeland). As with every ethnicity, there are quirks that are easily stereotyped. My sister passed this along to me and I had to say "yah" at how true some of these are!

YOU MIGHT BE DUTCH IF.......

  • You have a two volume address book, Volume I: A-U Volume II: V-Z.
  • You have never skipped church to watch the Super bowl.
  • Your main contribution to gender equality was the switch from King to Wilhelmina brand peppermints.
  • Your church attendance record is not disrupted by childbirth.
  • Your Sunday routine resembles: church, coffee, roast beef, jello salad, snooze, and church.
  • You have a living room but never sit in it.
  • All your cookies taste like almonds.
  • You make the bed in your hotel room.
  • You can sing "eere zij God" even though you can't speak Dutch.
  • Seeing raised hands during worship causes you to look around for a stick up man.
  • You are still trying to justify owning a dishwasher.
  • You have attended worship services at a campground amphitheater.
  • You know what an afghan is.
  • You have lace on your windows but not on your underwear.
  • All of your recipes are adapted to fit a 9 x 13 pan.
  • You can't imagine a funeral reception without ham buns.

Actual church bulletin announcements

Barbara C. remains in the hospital and needs blood donors for more transfusions. She is also having trouble sleeping and requests tapes of Pastor Jack's sermons.

The 'Over 60s Choir' will be disbanded for the summer with the thanks of the entire church.

Missionary from Africa speaking at ... church. Name Bertha Belch. Announcement: "Come tonight to hear Bertha Belch all the way from Africa."

Word study: Inheritance

God inherits the nation of Israel
- Isa 19:25; Psalm 94:14; 74:2; 28:9

Jesus inherits ALL the nations - Psalm 2:8; 82:8

Abraham/Israel inherits the land/world
- Gen 15:7; Hebrews 11:8; Romans 4:13; Matthew 5:5; Psalm 37:11

Levites inherit God Himself, instead of land with Israel - Joshua 13:33

Christians inherit:
a - inclusion in the body of Christ,
b - adoption as God's children,
c - salvation
- Ephesians 1:13-14; Colossians 1:12; Hebrews 6:12; 9:15; 1 Peter 1:3-4

Christians inherit a part of the Kingdom of God, as a reward for faithfulness
- Ephesians 5:5; Matthew 19:29; 25:34; Colossians 3:24; Revelation 21:7

Children inherit financially from parents
- Proverbs 13:22; 17:2; 19:14; 2 Corinthians 12:14

NT Wright


So far, this is an excellent book. The subtitle reveals an academic, and less-than-orthodox, audience, but Wright is actually on target on the doctrinal essentials.

His forte is summarizing past Pauline scholarship, clearing away the debris, and looking at what Paul was saying. Paul believed Jesus' death and resurrection and ascension fulfilled God's promises to redeem Israel, which meant it was now time to bring in the Gentiles, which was intended all along (Gen 12:3). So Paul went to the Gentiles with a Jewish message: the God of the Jews made all things and His redemption of the world has now reached you through Jesus, the true Lord (not Caesar) of all lords.

The justification chapters are next. Some of you are worried about those, I know. Going in, I believe the confessional understandings of justification are true to Scripture, but that there may be more that Paul said in the NT regarding this, than what the Westminster divines, e.g., summarized. See Vern Poythress' book, Symphonic Theology, to realize that the melody of confessional justification might be adorned and enhanced, not violated or altered, by various counter-melodies going on in Scripture. I expect to find those counter-melodies in Wright.

The Reformation was all about going ad fontes, back to the sources. Remember that the sources are Scripture, and only secondarily our confessions. We must define our theological terms using Scripture as our primary standard, not confessions or traditional language. Of course, we should also respect the great wisdom found in our forefather betters who wrote those confessions, and not readily accept new teachings opposing them, either.