7.17.2020

Advocacy Journalism (aka "Bias") Arrives at Christianity Today

Not that I've read Christianity Today much lately, but they have historically been the flagship publication of conservative evangelicalism.

No more.
https://www.christianitytoday.com/news/2020/july/andy-stanley-north-point-church-reopening-2021.html

They are now using the same advocacy tactics as the New York Times.
A misleading headline, meant to shape your view, has no corroboration to the actual facts in the article.

Here's the deets.

Headline: "More Pastors Agree with Andy Stanley: No Worship Services until 2021"
In the article: "In a Barna Group survey conducted over the past week, 5 percent of pastors said they didn’t expect to reopen this year. Just two months ago, none of the respondents were thinking it would be long."

Analysis: Okay.  I guess going from 0% to 5% is "more," technically.  But it's a bit obvious that CT with its headline is seeking to boost that number higher than 5%, or they wouldn't make a headline out of going from 0 to 5%.

This is grossly misguided, both to
- set up Stanley as a leader and figurehead of conservative pastors, which he is NOT
- and to seek to peer pressure (or "cool-shame") pastors into following a popular "pastor" to close out of fear of the virus.

And they quote Stanley as saying that focusing on getting back to in-person worship is "insider-focused."  That's weird.  It matters to God, the Bible says, that church leaders provide their people an in-person worship experience (Hebrews 10:24-25), for their own souls.  It's the on-line option that tends more to the consumer and insider in us all.

I'm in thorough agreement with a Facebook acquaintance, that Christianity Today is now "Christianity Astray."  Still some important news reported there, but their editorial choices are highly questionable.

No comments:

Post a Comment