Church History - a Review

Church History by Simonetta Carr
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This is a GREAT book. Geared as a textbook for roughly 7th-12th graders, Carr does an excellent job simplifying complex issues for students without dumbing things down. I used this as a homeschool text for a semester, and it was marvelous.

Carr is known for her shorter biographies of figures around the reformation, and applies her historical research more broadly, here.

Covering all of church history from 30AD to the present, worldwide, is quite a task, and some selectivity is needed. Here are some weaknesses, and then strengths of the book in this area.

Weaknesses:
The coverage is quite uneven. 30-1517AD is covered in 80 pages. Reformation to the present gets 170 pages. This is expected from a book published by “Reformation Heritage Books,” but still disappointing. Alfred the Great gets 2 sentences. Alcuin gets 3.

So many figures of history are given a little box with 2-3 sentences that I got ADD. It became just random facts, instead of a cohesive story.

The “Think about It” questions are helpful to engage students (and provide homework!), but they are often leading to a specific answer, rather than helping to think critically about a subject.

Strengths:
The visuals and high quality paper and binding are VERY well done. The book is beautiful and appealing, including many original portraits and pictures of historical figures, documents and assemblies.

The coverage of the Reformation through Westminster is thorough and excellent.

The coverage of history from 1900 on is the best I’ve seen anywhere, giving much detail and key figures I’d never heard of, worldwide from South Korea to Nigeria.


I don’t know if this is a strength or weakness, but the book is obviously from a Reformed Presbyterian perspective. It “takes sides” on the Arminius controversy and Dordt. Carr also is obviously keen to show that not only Baptists but Presbyterians sent out many missionaries in the 1800s. This makes her selective in modern history, focusing on Machen, Packer and Sproul, while Mohler’s historic reformation to orthodoxy of a major institution is absent.


Reformed homeschoolers should definitely get this book. Classical schools should consider it for their curriculum. We all need to know our history better, and this book provides a path to dip into history for as much time as you have. Either 5 minutes as a family devotion, or a semester as a high school course, Carr’s accomplishment brings you more understanding and spiritual edification from our Church family history.

View all my reviews